Grandmother, granddaughter say they put 200 grams gold in their bank locker in Hyderabad, but later 8 gold coins, two bars and some melted gold allegedly went missing; they blame bank negligence and seek compensation but consumer commission rejects appeal

Grandmother, granddaughter say they put 200 grams gold in their bank locker in Hyderabad, but later 8 gold coins, two bars and some melted gold allegedly went missing; they blame bank negligence and seek compensation but consumer commission rejects appeal
A woman and her granddaughter jointly held a bank locker in Hyderabad. (Image for representative purpose only)

A 79-year-old grandmother and her granddaughter alleged that gold coins, bars and melted gold had disappeared from their safe deposit locker at the bank. Holding the bank responsible for the alleged loss, they accused it of negligence and sought compensation.However, the Telangana State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has dismissed their appeal.In its September 2, 2026, the state commission ruled that the material placed on record was not sufficient to establish the bank’s liability for the alleged disappearance of the gold.The central question was whether the complainants had adequately demonstrated that the gold articles were deposited in the locker and subsequently went missing due to the bank’s negligence. Read on to know what happened

What the case is about

A woman and her granddaughter jointly held a locker at SBI’s Gunfoundry branch in Hyderabad. While the granddaughter was residing in Canada, the grandmother operated the locker in Hyderabad.The two alleged that they had deposited jewellery, pure gold coins, gold bars and melted gold weighing approximately 200 grams in the locker in 2015. They also said they had taken a photograph of the articles kept inside.The matter came to light in 2016, when the granddaughter visited the bank branch to collect the jewellery. According to the complaint, she discovered that eight pure gold coins, two gold bars and some melted gold were missing. The complainants alleged that she brought the matter to the branch manager’s attention but did not receive a satisfactory response.They subsequently approached the police station, following which a case was registered under Section 380 of the Indian Penal Code. As recorded in the judgment, the police classified the case as “undetectable”.The complainants contested the closure by filing a protest petition, which was still pending when the consumer commission delivered its decision.The complainants further claimed that the bank had halted their transactions and denied them access to the locker until they withdrew their complaint. The bank rejected these allegations, stating that the locker had been operated in accordance with the prescribed procedures.Explaining its position, the bank said that opening the locker required two keys, one retained by the customer and the other held by the bank. It argued that only the locker holders knew what had been stored inside and pointed out that there was no evidence of either the locker or the complainants’ personal lock having been broken open. The bank denied any negligence or deficiency in service.The District Consumer Commission rejected the complaint. The locker holders subsequently challenged the decision before the state commission, contending that the district forum had not properly assessed the photograph and other evidence they had placed on record.

Why consumer commission ruled against the claim

The commission’s assessment of the photograph was a key factor in its decision. It held that the image alone could not establish that the gold articles depicted in it had been placed inside the locker before the alleged theft.The state commission assessed the photograph and CD submitted by the complainants to support their claim that the gold articles had gone missing.It observed that the photograph depicted two large gold bars and a coin inside a plastic pouch.However, neither a date nor a signature appeared on the image. The commission found that the complainants had not produced any supporting material to establish that the articles visible in the photograph had been deposited in the locker before the alleged loss.The order observed: “In the absence of any collaborative evidence as to the depositing of the above contents in the locker by the complainants before the alleged loss/theft, merely basing on Ex.A2 photograph/CD which is undated and unsigned, its genuineness or otherwise cannot be decided/presumed.”The commission also considered whether the complainants had provided evidence of the locker being forcibly opened.No material had been submitted to show that their personal lock was damaged. This was considered alongside the findings of the police investigation, which had categorised the case as undetectable.While the police classification formed part of the evidence examined by the commission, it did not independently prove that the alleged gold had never been stored in the locker.The order stated: “In the instant case, there is no evidence on record adduced by the Complainants that the private lock placed on the locker was damaged nor any evidence of forcible opening of the locker, as a result of which the locker might have been broken.”The commission also took note of the Reserve Bank of India’s guidelines governing safe deposit lockers.It reproduced the 2007 guidance, which requires banks to exercise due care and adopt necessary precautions to safeguard lockers. The guidance also calls for regular reviews of security arrangements, proper documentation of procedures and compliance with those procedures by bank staff.The commission also examined the nature of the relationship between a bank and its locker holders under the applicable guidelines.It described this relationship as one between a lessor and a hirer, rather than a bailor and a bailee, and reproduced a provision dealing with the bank’s responsibility for loss of or damage to articles kept in lockers.The order also explained how lockers are ordinarily operated. Under the procedure described by the commission, the customer and the bank official use their respective keys to open the locker.After it is opened, the bank official leaves the strong room, allowing the customer to access and handle the contents privately.The commission observed that bank employees are generally not present when customers use their lockers and, consequently, cannot verify the articles deposited or removed.The commission additionally relied on the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission’s ruling in Mamta Chaudaha & Anr vs Branch Manager/Head Manager, delivered on December 20, 2019. Referring to this precedent, it held that the complainants’ claim that the gold had been stolen because of negligence or deficiency in service could not be upheld in the absence of supporting evidence.Summing up its findings, the commission held: “In view of our afforested discussion we hold that the complainants/appellants are not entitled for any of the claims.”Accordingly, it rejected the appeal and upheld the District Commission’s decision, without imposing any costs. At the same time, it specifically permitted the complainants to pursue their pending protest petition and seek an appropriate legal remedy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *