The batting conditions in India’s five-match ODI series against New Zealand, which ended on Sunday, were far from straightforward, especially under lights. The ball moved in the air and off the pitch, while the tennis-ball bounce gave pacers plenty to work with.Even so, Rohit Sharma’s returns were stark: 0 off 6, 23 off 28, 0 off 1 and 7 off 13. Looking leaden-footed on seamer-friendly surfaces and far removed from the batter who has scored 12,150 runs in 296 ODIs at 48.60, with 35 centuries, 63 fifties and a world-record 264, the 39-year-old managed just 30 runs in four innings at 7.50.For a player who has dominated ODI cricket since moving to the top of the order in 2013, such a lean run is rare. This was his 26th overseas ODI series across nearly two decades, and only the third in which he averaged in single digits. On three occasions, he has averaged more than 100.The only time he fared worse across at least four innings was against Sri Lanka 14 years ago, a series he later described as the worst of his career. Rohit made just 13 runs in five matches, averaging 2.60. Rohit’s dismissals in New Zealand exposed his struggles against the moving ball. He fell to Jamieson in Auckland and Wellington, edged Matt Henry at Mount Maunganui and picked out midwicket off Matthew Fisher in his final innings.With the 2027 ODI World Cup approaching, every failure will fuel the age debate. Rohit was 39 years and 199 days old in his last ODI and will be 40 years and 180 days old when India face Australia in their World Cup opener in Cape Town. Every lean series will inevitably raise questions about his place in the team.He will have opportunities to regain form in the home ODI series against Sri Lanka, beginning in Vi-zag on Dec 13, and Zimbabwe, starting in Kolkata on Jan 3, 2027. Howe-ver, India’s batting-friendly pitches may not test his reflexes as seve-rely as New Zealand’s conditions.

Rohit’s struggles have brought India’s alternatives into focus, with young openers Yashasvi Jaiswal, Vaibhav Sooryavanshi and Abhishek Sharma waiting for opportunities. Jaiswal, in particular, has been unlucky, having scored 285 runs at 71.25, including two centuries, in just six ODIs but struggled to find a regular place behind Rohit and Shubman Gill.The debate is now unavoidable: should Rohit play the 2027 World Cup? And are India running out of time to prepare alternatives if his form does not improve?There is a cautionary precedent in MS Dhoni’s final phase. The former India captain, an all-time white-ball great, found it increasingly difficult to force the pace during the 2019 World Cup in England, where India exited in the semifinals. Will Rohit’s final lap follow a similar path, or can he rediscover his touch and sign off on his own terms?It is no secret that the selectors had initially looked beyond Rohit for the 2027 World Cup and indicated that Lord’s could be his final appearance in India colours. However, the Mumbaikar convinced the BCCI hierarchy of his worth and his desire to continue until the global event.That raises another question: was former chief selector and India pacer Ajit Agarkar right to question Rohit’s place in the ODI side, even as the BCCI backed the superstar’s World Cup ambitions? The reported disagreement between the two only sharpened the issue.Much will now depend on how the new selection committee, headed by former left-arm spinner Pragyan Ojha, views Rohit’s form and future. Ojha, a former India and Mumbai Indians teammate of Rohit, will face a difficult call if the batter’s lean run continues. Selection meetings are also attended by Centre of Excellence chairperson and former India batter VVS Laxman.There is precedent for selectors making tough calls on established stars. During his tenure as chief selector from 2012 to 2016, former India batter Sandeep Patil oversaw the transition away from several greats, most notably Sachin Tendulkar.Patil, however, believes Rohit deserves time to regain form and has backed him to make the World Cup squad. “Rohit and Virat are the kind of players whose class is permanent. Form is temporary. Not scoring runs in a series can happen. What is more important is the 2027 ODI World Cup, not this ODI series in New Zealand. As a big fan of Rohit, I would love to see him in the World Cup, but the decision remains with the selectors and Rohit,” Patil told TOI on Monday.He said there was still almost a year to go before the tournament, giving Rohit time to recover, provided he stayed fit and competitive.
